Freeze-Dried Cat Treats: Naughty or Mice vs Santa Claws
By UPCO Pet Supplies | Small Business Pet Shop in St. Joseph MO | Published: 2026-10-24
Category: Comparisons
Compare GivePet Naughty or Mice salmon treats and Santa Claws chicken treats. Find out which freeze-dried cat snack fits your cat's taste and dietary needs this holiday season.
Quick answer
For a novel protein option, choose GivePet Naughty or Mice Salmon treats; for a classic, widely accepted flavor, go with GivePet Santa Claws Chicken treats.
Why protein source matters
Cats are obligate carnivores, so the protein source in their treats directly affects palatability and digestion. Salmon offers a different amino acid profile and is often less common in daily diets, making it a good choice for cats who need variety or have sensitivities to poultry. Chicken is a familiar, easily digestible protein that most cats accept readily.
Holiday packaging and appeal
Both treats come in festive packaging that adds a seasonal touch to treat time. The Naughty or Mice bag features a playful holiday design, while Santa Claws has a classic Christmas look. The packaging difference is cosmetic—the real decision should be based on your cat's protein preference.
Trade-offs at a glance
- Protein novelty: Naughty or Mice uses salmon, a less common protein that can help avoid food boredom or sensitivities. Santa Claws uses chicken, which is familiar and usually well-tolerated.
- Palatability certainty: Chicken treats have a higher likelihood of being accepted by most cats. Salmon may be a hit or miss depending on your cat's individual taste. If your cat has never had salmon, buy the smaller 1 oz bag to test first.
- Treat size and value: Naughty or Mice comes in a 1 oz bag (catalog price $4.96), while Santa Claws offers 1.25 oz for $5.17. The Santa Claws bag provides slightly more volume for the price. For households with multiple cats, the extra 0.25 oz in Santa Claws may stretch further.
Product facts
- GivePet Naughty or Mice Salmon Freeze-Dried Cat Treats 1 oz: Single-source salmon protein with no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Salmon is a novel protein for many cats, making it a great option for cats with poultry sensitivities or those who need dietary variety.
GivePet Naughty or Mice Salmon Freeze-Dried Cat Treats 1 oz - GivePet Santa Claws Chicken Breast Freeze-Dried Cat Treats 1.25 oz: Single-source chicken breast protein with no artificial colors, flavors or preservatives. Chicken is a widely accepted protein that most cats love, making this a safe bet for picky eaters or multi-cat households.
GivePet Santa Claws Chicken Breast Freeze-Dried Cat Treats 1.25 oz
Which treat fits your cat?
Best for
- Cats who enjoy or need a novel protein like salmon
- Owners looking for a poultry-free treat option
Not ideal for
- Cats who are extremely picky and have never accepted salmon treats
- Owners who prefer a larger bag for the price point
